Call Us Now

Quamme Insurance Services

The First Source for Home and Auto Insurance in Columbus and Madison, WI


Quamme Insurance Services, Inc. is family-owned and operated and has delivered top-quality insurance and risk management solutions for decades.  We offer a diverse group of personal and commercial insurance packages and can meet almost any asset-protection need.  Our team is committed to providing personalized services and to assisting clients in any way it can.


  We offer personal lines of coverage that range from home and auto to recreational vehicle and personal umbrella.  On the commercial side, we offer coverage for farmers and agribusinesses, as well as for local and niche-industry businesses such as flower shops, salons, and medical practices.  Whether we provide personal or commercial insurance, and no matter what coverages are included in this insurance, our goal is to find the right mix of coverage and cost so that our clients get the most value.  


We’re local and know the areas we serve well.  Our agents grew up in these areas and have firsthand experience on farms and in other businesses that are well known locally.  We’re proud to be a partner to local organizations and to residents of our communities; it helps us contribute to the world around us not only by being insurers but by being good citizens and neighbors as well.


If you would like to learn more, please contact an agent in Columbus, Beaver Dam, or Poynette or give us a call.  You can also request a quote to get started on a policy.  


Question on a Claim? Click here!



Check out our online listings and leave a review!

Read Unbiased Consumer Reviews Online at       


Find us on social media!






Quamme Insurance places a high priority on customer satisfaction and strives for excellence and professionalism in every area of responsibility. They pay attention to detail to insure we have the correct coverage if we were to have a claim.
Adam F
We have both our personal and business insurance with Quamme Insurance and their claims service is exceptional on both fronts. Over the past five years, we've had a vehicle accident and water damage to our building. Both claims were handled promptly, compassionately and without hassle. We've even received follow-up calls after the claims were settled to make sure that nothing else had happened that needed to be taken care of. Thank you to Erik, his staff and Allied claims people for making our insurance claims an easy process.
Dan M.
Quamme Insurance places a high priority on customer satisfaction and strives for excellence and professionalism in every area of responsibility. They are proactive, advocate for the customer and assist with claims to make sure I am taken care of. Thank you Quamme Insurance for the peace of mind I have working with you!
Dr. Adam Forster
I have had the opportunity to work with Erik on a professional level, to be a customer of his and to recommend his services to my friends and family. I believe that Erik is a rarity in the insurance business. He is focused on doing business the right way by thoroughly explaining the products that he is marketing and then backing it up with service that is unmatched in the industry. If you are shopping for insurance, I would make Quamme Insurance your first call.
Gary G.

Our Locations

Columbus Location

1130 Park Ave
Columbus, WI 53925
Main office: 920-623-5787
Toll free: 888-753-9232

Beaver Dam Location

Quamme Insurance
Beaver Dam, WI 53916
Main office: 920-887-8868
Toll free: 888-753-9232

Poynette Location

Quamme Insurance
Poynette, WI 53955
Main office: 608-635-8001
Toll free: 888-753-9232