Call Us Now

Quamme Cares about our Community! 

We at Quamme Insurance is honored to be a part of our great community, and we feel that we should give back to the place that has given us so much! Check back frequently to see how we are giving back as well as when community events are going on! 

Breakfast with Santa

We donated 250 water bottles for the "Breakfast with Santa" event at the Columbus Country Club on Saturday 12/6/14! Thank you Tim Hoffman for putting this event on! These will be put into goody bags for the kids who attend. I also have 250 left at the office so if you would like a free water bottle stop by our office at 1130 Park Ave in Columbus!!! Click the link below for more information.

Breakfast with Santa

Columbus High School & Poynette High School Business Class

On Monday 10/27/14 we were asked to teach two different business classes at Columbus High School. Our purpose is to prepare these young adults for the responsibilities they will face now and after they graduate from high school. First we discussed auto liability, vehicles titles, what factors affect premiums and what they can expect to pay for coverage. As they transition from high school to college and live in dorms/apartments, we talked about the importance of renters insurance and how that covers personal property loss and personal liability situations. The affordable care act was a hot topic and was an eye opener for the students when they learned what deductibles, co-insurance and monthly premium costs they will face when they pay for health coverage. We touched on the different kinds of life insurance and the reasons why it is important and we concluded with carriers in the insurance arena. It was a fun day and we are glad we are able to work with the kids!

Basketball Donation

Each year we donate basketballs to youth programs in Columbus, Fall River & Poynette WI. We really enjoy giving back and helping enstill the love of sports, a healthy lifestyle, and sportsmanship to the kids in our area!

Vision Screenings

Erik Quamme, along with our local Lions Club do vision screenings for 3-5 year olds in 4 local communities to make sure that each child in our community is happy and healthy.

3 Scoreboards Dontated!

We are proud to announce that we have donated to 3 scoreboard projects at Columbus High School Gym & Football Field and in 2014 we donated to the Lions Park in Columbus for their softball field. We can't wait to see them light up each season! 

Lions/Meister Park Basketball Court

We love sports and love being able to give back to the sports that we love! Erik helped build a basketball court for the Meister/Lions Park. Hopefully anyone who plays on the park will love it as much as we do! 

Hanna's Hope

We love donating to causes that directly help the people in the community. We donated to Hanna's Hope, to help 3 local women who have been diagnosed with cancer. 

American Heart Association Bike Ride

In 2012, Erik rode his bicycle from Canada to the Gulf of Mexico over 18 days to raise money for the American Heart Association

Check out this news article to see the journey that he took. 

Our Locations

Columbus Location

Columbus Location

1130 Park Ave
Columbus, WI 53925
Main office: 920-623-5787
Toll free: 888-753-9232
Beaver Dam Location

Beaver Dam Location

Quamme Insurance
Beaver Dam, WI 53916
Main office: 920-887-8868
Toll free: 888-753-9232
Poynette Location

Poynette Location

Quamme Insurance
Poynette, WI 53955
Main office: 608-635-8001
Toll free: 888-753-9232

Our Providers


I have a very helpful review. I run Denny's Auto Body in Columbus WI., I deal with 10 or more insurance companies/agents per week. Whenever Quamme insurance or the companies they offer are involved in a claim with our shop, the process is extremely smooth. That can not be said for MOST of the other companies we deal with. That is why I have my personal autos, home, and business all with Quamme Insurance. Great customer service!
Bodie Colotti
Quamme insurance has been hands down the best insurance company i have ever had. Not only do they have great competitive rates but the customer service is top notch! Im looking forward to many more years of service with Quamme insurance.
jason kowing
Erik and staff at Quamme Insurance have always been quick to respond to any needs, and always have the best interest of the client/customer in mind. Honest and hardworking, and have recommended to several friends and colleagues.
Christine Frodel
Quamme Insurance places a high priority on customer satisfaction and strives for excellence and professionalism in every area of responsibility. They pay attention to detail to insure we have the correct coverage if we were to have a claim.
Adam F
We have both our personal and business insurance with Quamme Insurance and their claims service is exceptional on both fronts. Over the past five years, we've had a vehicle accident and water damage to our building. Both claims were handled promptly, compassionately and without hassle. We've even received follow-up calls after the claims were settled to make sure that nothing else had happened that needed to be taken care of. Thank you to Erik, his staff and Allied claims people for making our insurance claims an easy process.
Dan M.
Quamme Insurance places a high priority on customer satisfaction and strives for excellence and professionalism in every area of responsibility. They are proactive, advocate for the customer and assist with claims to make sure I am taken care of. Thank you Quamme Insurance for the peace of mind I have working with you!
Dr. Adam Forster
I have had the opportunity to work with Erik on a professional level, to be a customer of his and to recommend his services to my friends and family. I believe that Erik is a rarity in the insurance business. He is focused on doing business the right way by thoroughly explaining the products that he is marketing and then backing it up with service that is unmatched in the industry. If you are shopping for insurance, I would make Quamme Insurance your first call.
Gary G.