Call Us Now

Auto Insurance for Columbus and Madison, WI Area Residents

Keeping Our Drivers Protected

Auto Insurance

From theft to vandalism and collisions, the risks that drivers and car owners face are numerous and auto insurance is imperative for anyone wanting to stay protected behind the wheel.  At Quamme Insurance Services, Inc., we run a diverse auto insurance program that protects against all risks our neighbors face.  You will be free of concern for unnecessary losses as we tailor this program to you and your family’s story.  You’ll have the best policy for right price.

Finding Coverage Tailored to You

General auto insurance can protect against a variety of risks, but additional coverage may be necessary to cover all the bases. We will closely evaluate your car’s needs and the geographic risks to make sure your solution is comprehensive.  By working with a variety of different carriers, your policy will have the greatest possible selection that you won’t find at big-box shops.  Use these options to customize your policy so that it’s the best fit, namely:

  • Liability Coverage
  • Comprehensive Coverage
  • Collision Coverage
  • Uninsured & Underinsured Motorist Coverage
  • Diminishing Deductible
  • Accident Forgiveness
  • Minor Violation Forgiveness
  • Roadside Assistance
  • Specialty Auto Insurance
  • 24-Hour Customer Service
  • Towing
  • Rental Reimbursement
  • Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
  • Medical Payments Coverage

If you combine your auto insurance with your home insurance, you can save money and time.  We’ll design the combination for you; just visit our home & auto page and/or speak with an agent.

What to Expect

Through constant attention to our customers, they rest easy knowing they have the right solutions at a favorable price.  We work closely to identify the best ways to combine excellent coverage with cost-efficient solutions.  We constantly monitor the industry and its pertinence to your situation.  We actively manage risk and should you need to file a claim, we will handle the entire process so you don’t have to.  We make ourselves available as often as possible so we are there when you need us most.

Please contact us or give us a call to learn more.  You can get stared by requesting a quote.

Additional Insurance Information:

Quamme Insurance Services, Inc. provides Home Insurance for residents near Columbus, Madison, Sun Prairie, Beaver Dam, Poynette, and Juneau.  We also serve other areas of the state.

Related Products:

Our Locations

Columbus Location

Columbus Location

1130 Park Ave
Columbus, WI 53925
Main office: 920-623-5787
Toll free: 888-753-9232
Beaver Dam Location

Beaver Dam Location

Quamme Insurance
Beaver Dam, WI 53916
Main office: 920-887-8868
Toll free: 888-753-9232
Poynette Location

Poynette Location

Quamme Insurance
Poynette, WI 53955
Main office: 608-635-8001
Toll free: 888-753-9232

Our Providers


I have a very helpful review. I run Denny's Auto Body in Columbus WI., I deal with 10 or more insurance companies/agents per week. Whenever Quamme insurance or the companies they offer are involved in a claim with our shop, the process is extremely smooth. That can not be said for MOST of the other companies we deal with. That is why I have my personal autos, home, and business all with Quamme Insurance. Great customer service!
Bodie Colotti
Quamme insurance has been hands down the best insurance company i have ever had. Not only do they have great competitive rates but the customer service is top notch! Im looking forward to many more years of service with Quamme insurance.
jason kowing
Erik and staff at Quamme Insurance have always been quick to respond to any needs, and always have the best interest of the client/customer in mind. Honest and hardworking, and have recommended to several friends and colleagues.
Christine Frodel
Quamme Insurance places a high priority on customer satisfaction and strives for excellence and professionalism in every area of responsibility. They pay attention to detail to insure we have the correct coverage if we were to have a claim.
Adam F
We have both our personal and business insurance with Quamme Insurance and their claims service is exceptional on both fronts. Over the past five years, we've had a vehicle accident and water damage to our building. Both claims were handled promptly, compassionately and without hassle. We've even received follow-up calls after the claims were settled to make sure that nothing else had happened that needed to be taken care of. Thank you to Erik, his staff and Allied claims people for making our insurance claims an easy process.
Dan M.
Quamme Insurance places a high priority on customer satisfaction and strives for excellence and professionalism in every area of responsibility. They are proactive, advocate for the customer and assist with claims to make sure I am taken care of. Thank you Quamme Insurance for the peace of mind I have working with you!
Dr. Adam Forster
I have had the opportunity to work with Erik on a professional level, to be a customer of his and to recommend his services to my friends and family. I believe that Erik is a rarity in the insurance business. He is focused on doing business the right way by thoroughly explaining the products that he is marketing and then backing it up with service that is unmatched in the industry. If you are shopping for insurance, I would make Quamme Insurance your first call.
Gary G.